"AND FUNCTION" RETURNS FALSE WHEN CRITERIA IS TRUELY MET. HELP!!!

I have a problem using AND function on date data.

In cell A2, I have date date "10/1/2009".

In cell A3, I have AND fuction as =AND(A2=10/1/2009, A2=10/24/2009). This
should return a TRUE but instead returns FALSE. Why?


Thank you, BB

The issue is how you expressed your dates

Try =AND(A2=DATE(2009,10,1),A2=DATE(2009,10,24))

As written Excel does not recognize 10/1/2009 as a date, it does the math 10
divided by 1 divided by 2009
--
If this helps, please remember to click yes.


"gamn" wrote:

I have a problem using AND function on date data.

In cell A2, I have date date "10/1/2009".

In cell A3, I have AND fuction as =AND(A2=10/1/2009, A2=10/24/2009). This
should return a TRUE but instead returns FALSE. Why?


Thank you, BB

On Tue, 23 Mar 2010 13:47:01 -0700, gamn
wrote:

In cell A2, I have date date "10/1/2009".

In cell A3, I have AND fuction as =AND(A2=10/1/2009, A2=10/24/2009). This
should return a TRUE but instead returns FALSE. Why?

because 10/1/2009 is not the same as "10/1/2009"

The latter, in A2, is interpreted as a date and stored as an integer probably
equal to 40087, depending on the date system you are using in Excel.

The former: 10/1/2009 is computed as 10÷1÷2009 or 0.004978.

To unambiguously enter a date into your formula, you should either use a cell
reference containing the date, or use the DATE function. eg:

=and(a2=date(2009,10,1),a2=date(2009,10,24))

--ron

I tried that but still a NO-GO. See link for a screen shot.


https://emerson.sendthisfile.com/Gvn...YGVN1QSDhpQeoc

Thank you, BB

"Paul C" wrote:

The issue is how you expressed your dates

Try =AND(A2=DATE(2009,10,1),A2=DATE(2009,10,24))

As written Excel does not recognize 10/1/2009 as a date, it does the math 10
divided by 1 divided by 2009
--
If this helps, please remember to click yes.


"gamn" wrote:

I have a problem using AND function on date data.

In cell A2, I have date date "10/1/2009".

In cell A3, I have AND fuction as =AND(A2=10/1/2009, A2=10/24/2009). This
should return a TRUE but instead returns FALSE. Why?


Thank you, BB

As explained by Paul, the order of parameters for the Date function is:
year, month, day.

Regards,
Fred

"gamn" wrote in message
...
I tried that but still a NO-GO. See link for a screen shot.


https://emerson.sendthisfile.com/Gvn...YGVN1QSDhpQeoc

Thank you, BB

"Paul C" wrote:

The issue is how you expressed your dates

Try =AND(A2=DATE(2009,10,1),A2=DATE(2009,10,24))

As written Excel does not recognize 10/1/2009 as a date, it does the math
10
divided by 1 divided by 2009
--
If this helps, please remember to click yes.


"gamn" wrote:

I have a problem using AND function on date data.

In cell A2, I have date date "10/1/2009".

In cell A3, I have AND fuction as =AND(A2=10/1/2009, A2=10/24/2009).
This
should return a TRUE but instead returns FALSE. Why?


Thank you, BB

But you did not follow Paul's advice! The syntax of the DATE function is
DATE(year, month, day). This is totally independent of you preferred data
format. In the screen capture you linked us to you have DATE(10,1,2009)
when you need DATE(2009,10,1)
best wishes
--
Bernard Liengme
Microsoft Excel MVP
http://people.stfx.ca/bliengme

"gamn" wrote in message
...
I tried that but still a NO-GO. See link for a screen shot.


https://emerson.sendthisfile.com/Gvn...YGVN1QSDhpQeoc

Thank you, BB

"Paul C" wrote:

The issue is how you expressed your dates

Try =AND(A2=DATE(2009,10,1),A2=DATE(2009,10,24))

As written Excel does not recognize 10/1/2009 as a date, it does the math
10
divided by 1 divided by 2009
--
If this helps, please remember to click yes.


"gamn" wrote:

I have a problem using AND function on date data.

In cell A2, I have date date "10/1/2009".

In cell A3, I have AND fuction as =AND(A2=10/1/2009, A2=10/24/2009).
This
should return a TRUE but instead returns FALSE. Why?


Thank you, BB