Comments in Charts

Two years ago Mike P. from KC asked:
"Is it possible to have a data cell's comment (which shows up on mouse-over
of
the red triangle in the upper right of the cell) also show up on mouse-over
of the data point on a chart that takes a data point or points from a
"commented on" cell(s)? If so, how can you do it? "

The only reply was from Jon Peltier: "This isn't a native Excel capability,
but it's an interesting idea, and one that could be accomplished using VBA."

Does anyone know if this has been done yet? If so how could I get that macro?

It remains an interesting idea. I've had no further interest in it until
now.

I haven't addressed this problem yet, because it's a multiple-part routine.
It requires chart events to detect a mouseover on the chart, it requires
parsing of the chart data to determine which cell contains the data point's
value, and it requires reading and displaying of the comment.

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
Peltier Technical Services, Inc. - http://PeltierTech.com
_______


"Fred Zack" wrote in message
...
Two years ago Mike P. from KC asked:
"Is it possible to have a data cell's comment (which shows up on
mouse-over
of
the red triangle in the upper right of the cell) also show up on
mouse-over
of the data point on a chart that takes a data point or points from a
"commented on" cell(s)? If so, how can you do it? "

The only reply was from Jon Peltier: "This isn't a native Excel
capability,
but it's an interesting idea, and one that could be accomplished using
VBA."

Does anyone know if this has been done yet? If so how could I get that
macro?

AFter more digging I found that actually Jon, you did supply an answer of
sorts on Oct of 2006 : "Marie -

Excel doesn't have this capability built-in, but it is flexible enough that
clever programmers can provide similar functionality. In this case, the
clever programmer is my colleague Tushar Mehta. On his web site
(http://tushar-mehta.com) is a utility called Chart Hover Labels, which will
do what you need.

- Jon"

I am going to try it out and see how it works. Problem is it seems rather
"all or none". I would like to have a data label and then show more detail on
rollover, but I think Hover Chart Label just wants to ONLY show when you
hover.


"Jon Peltier" wrote:

It remains an interesting idea. I've had no further interest in it until
now.

I haven't addressed this problem yet, because it's a multiple-part routine.
It requires chart events to detect a mouseover on the chart, it requires
parsing of the chart data to determine which cell contains the data point's
value, and it requires reading and displaying of the comment.

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
Peltier Technical Services, Inc. - http://PeltierTech.com
_______


"Fred Zack" wrote in message
...
Two years ago Mike P. from KC asked:
"Is it possible to have a data cell's comment (which shows up on
mouse-over
of
the red triangle in the upper right of the cell) also show up on
mouse-over
of the data point on a chart that takes a data point or points from a
"commented on" cell(s)? If so, how can you do it? "

The only reply was from Jon Peltier: "This isn't a native Excel
capability,
but it's an interesting idea, and one that could be accomplished using
VBA."

Does anyone know if this has been done yet? If so how could I get that
macro?

Does not appear to be working corrrectly. I just get the labels displayed
permenatly or get a Run-Time error message. Maybe this is due to "limited
testing" with Excel versions 97, 2000 and 2002. I have 2002. So no answer to
question yet.

"Fred Zack" wrote:

AFter more digging I found that actually Jon, you did supply an answer of
sorts on Oct of 2006 : "Marie -

Excel doesn't have this capability built-in, but it is flexible enough that
clever programmers can provide similar functionality. In this case, the
clever programmer is my colleague Tushar Mehta. On his web site
(http://tushar-mehta.com) is a utility called Chart Hover Labels, which will
do what you need.

- Jon"

I am going to try it out and see how it works. Problem is it seems rather
"all or none". I would like to have a data label and then show more detail on
rollover, but I think Hover Chart Label just wants to ONLY show when you
hover.


"Jon Peltier" wrote:

It remains an interesting idea. I've had no further interest in it until
now.

I haven't addressed this problem yet, because it's a multiple-part routine.
It requires chart events to detect a mouseover on the chart, it requires
parsing of the chart data to determine which cell contains the data point's
value, and it requires reading and displaying of the comment.

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
Peltier Technical Services, Inc. - http://PeltierTech.com
_______


"Fred Zack" wrote in message
...
Two years ago Mike P. from KC asked:
"Is it possible to have a data cell's comment (which shows up on
mouse-over
of
the red triangle in the upper right of the cell) also show up on
mouse-over
of the data point on a chart that takes a data point or points from a
"commented on" cell(s)? If so, how can you do it? "

The only reply was from Jon Peltier: "This isn't a native Excel
capability,
but it's an interesting idea, and one that could be accomplished using
VBA."

Does anyone know if this has been done yet? If so how could I get that
macro?

Hover Chart Label operates independently of any data labels. Apply the data
labels you want, using one of these add-ins if the built-in options don't
show what you want:

Rob Bovey's Chart Labeler, http://appspro.com
John Walkenbach's Chart Tools, http://j-walk.com

Then use Tushar's utility for the labels that show when you mouse over the
points.

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
Peltier Technical Services, Inc. - http://PeltierTech.com
_______


"Fred Zack" wrote in message
...
AFter more digging I found that actually Jon, you did supply an answer of
sorts on Oct of 2006 : "Marie -

Excel doesn't have this capability built-in, but it is flexible enough
that
clever programmers can provide similar functionality. In this case, the
clever programmer is my colleague Tushar Mehta. On his web site
(http://tushar-mehta.com) is a utility called Chart Hover Labels, which
will
do what you need.

- Jon"

I am going to try it out and see how it works. Problem is it seems rather
"all or none". I would like to have a data label and then show more detail
on
rollover, but I think Hover Chart Label just wants to ONLY show when you
hover.


"Jon Peltier" wrote:

It remains an interesting idea. I've had no further interest in it until
now.

I haven't addressed this problem yet, because it's a multiple-part
routine.
It requires chart events to detect a mouseover on the chart, it requires
parsing of the chart data to determine which cell contains the data
point's
value, and it requires reading and displaying of the comment.

- Jon
-------
Jon Peltier, Microsoft Excel MVP
Tutorials and Custom Solutions
Peltier Technical Services, Inc. - http://PeltierTech.com
_______


"Fred Zack" wrote in message
...
Two years ago Mike P. from KC asked:
"Is it possible to have a data cell's comment (which shows up on
mouse-over
of
the red triangle in the upper right of the cell) also show up on
mouse-over
of the data point on a chart that takes a data point or points from a
"commented on" cell(s)? If so, how can you do it? "

The only reply was from Jon Peltier: "This isn't a native Excel
capability,
but it's an interesting idea, and one that could be accomplished using
VBA."

Does anyone know if this has been done yet? If so how could I get that
macro?