If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
How to get data from Analysis Services cubes into Access
Our users are keen on using Access Reports/Queries against Analysis
Services cubes for formatted reporting. Please let me know how I could connect to Analysis Services cubes and report in Access. Thanks Karen |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
You would be better off looking at reporting services for something
like this I think. I don't think anyone on this group would recommend using access for this. if you want to mail me I can point you in the right direction of people who can provide services etc. or even some better recommendations if you can give me some more information on the requirement. Steve |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
personally, I would reccomend using Access over Reporting Services-- but
these jerks at Microsoft are too afraid to deal with the markeing problems associated with Access. Access Reports against OLAP would be AWESOME "Steve McHugh" wrote in message ups.com... You would be better off looking at reporting services for something like this I think. I don't think anyone on this group would recommend using access for this. if you want to mail me I can point you in the right direction of people who can provide services etc. or even some better recommendations if you can give me some more information on the requirement. Steve |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
ps, it is easy to flatten hierarchial recordsets using OLAP as a linked
server to SQL Server. So you go to your SQL Server, you setup OLAP as a linked server; and then you can use OLAP data in Access however you want. This way, you only have to install OLAP drivers in once place-- on the db server. Since installing OLAP drivers is like 1/2 of the complexity of implementing OLAP, I really reccomend it. Personally, Microsoft keeps on screwing around with drivers, just so that they can keep on squeezing office upgrades out of people. -aaron "Karen Middleton" wrote in message om... Our users are keen on using Access Reports/Queries against Analysis Services cubes for formatted reporting. Please let me know how I could connect to Analysis Services cubes and report in Access. Thanks Karen |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Steve
I am just curious-- what is your major problem with Access? Are you too stupid to know that the default repository in OLAP uses Access; and that Access/JET drives these products: EXCHANGE OUTLOOK PROJECT MONEY WINDOWS ACTIVE DIRECTORY I just dont like your bigotry against Access. Access is the best solution for many situations-- I don't like your attitude. Karen--- fight the power, Access rocks. WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! "Steve McHugh" wrote in message ups.com... You would be better off looking at reporting services for something like this I think. I don't think anyone on this group would recommend using access for this. if you want to mail me I can point you in the right direction of people who can provide services etc. or even some better recommendations if you can give me some more information on the requirement. Steve |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Aaron
In the same way that you don't like Steve's attitude (I would prefer to use the word opinion), I don't care for your rude reply. This online community is for friendly help and assistance, not for trading insults. Your use of the word "bigotry" is unwarranted. As I said, Steve was merely stating his opinion. AS does indeed use Access as its default repository. Doubtless Microsoft would rather have been able to default the repository to an enterprise RDBMS (for all the benefits that it brings) but many/most people simply don't have one of these at their disposal. Yes yes, I know that if you have AS then you have SQL Server but thats not the whole story. Microsoft have also realised the folly of relying on a seperate storage medium for the repository and have done away wth this completely in Yukon. In my opinion Access is not a viable solution for deploying enterprise-wide reports. One simple reason for this is that it requires software to be installed on users' machines. Reporting Services (to take one such example) only requires a web browser which everyone has anyway. I myself do not care much for access due to problems I have experienced with it in the past around concurrent access, .mdb file size explosion (by orders of magnitude), limited programability and lack of logging capability. If there was a significant requirement for Access reports against OLAP in the user community then I'm sure Microsoft would provide it. That they haven't probably means the requirement isn't there. Regards Jamie Thomson "aaron kempf" wrote: Steve I am just curious-- what is your major problem with Access? Are you too stupid to know that the default repository in OLAP uses Access; and that Access/JET drives these products: EXCHANGE OUTLOOK PROJECT MONEY WINDOWS ACTIVE DIRECTORY I just dont like your bigotry against Access. Access is the best solution for many situations-- I don't like your attitude. Karen--- fight the power, Access rocks. WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! "Steve McHugh" wrote in message ups.com... You would be better off looking at reporting services for something like this I think. I don't think anyone on this group would recommend using access for this. if you want to mail me I can point you in the right direction of people who can provide services etc. or even some better recommendations if you can give me some more information on the requirement. Steve |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Jamie -- Agreed....
/Michael Vardinghus "Jamie Thomson" wrote in message ... Aaron In the same way that you don't like Steve's attitude (I would prefer to use the word opinion), I don't care for your rude reply. This online community is for friendly help and assistance, not for trading insults. Your use of the word "bigotry" is unwarranted. As I said, Steve was merely stating his opinion. AS does indeed use Access as its default repository. Doubtless Microsoft would rather have been able to default the repository to an enterprise RDBMS (for all the benefits that it brings) but many/most people simply don't have one of these at their disposal. Yes yes, I know that if you have AS then you have SQL Server but thats not the whole story. Microsoft have also realised the folly of relying on a seperate storage medium for the repository and have done away wth this completely in Yukon. In my opinion Access is not a viable solution for deploying enterprise-wide reports. One simple reason for this is that it requires software to be installed on users' machines. Reporting Services (to take one such example) only requires a web browser which everyone has anyway. I myself do not care much for access due to problems I have experienced with it in the past around concurrent access, .mdb file size explosion (by orders of magnitude), limited programability and lack of logging capability. If there was a significant requirement for Access reports against OLAP in the user community then I'm sure Microsoft would provide it. That they haven't probably means the requirement isn't there. Regards Jamie Thomson "aaron kempf" wrote: Steve I am just curious-- what is your major problem with Access? Are you too stupid to know that the default repository in OLAP uses Access; and that Access/JET drives these products: EXCHANGE OUTLOOK PROJECT MONEY WINDOWS ACTIVE DIRECTORY I just dont like your bigotry against Access. Access is the best solution for many situations-- I don't like your attitude. Karen--- fight the power, Access rocks. WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! WE DEMAND ACCESS REPORTS AGAINST OLAP!!!!!! "Steve McHugh" wrote in message ups.com... You would be better off looking at reporting services for something like this I think. I don't think anyone on this group would recommend using access for this. if you want to mail me I can point you in the right direction of people who can provide services etc. or even some better recommendations if you can give me some more information on the requirement. Steve |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Geez,
don't you hate it when you go away for a few hours and come back and find this...... Let me clarify a few points..... Firstly I have nothing against Access. Hey I learnt my trade on it to start with and found it to very useful when creating nice small, easliy distributable, single user databases with some reporting bolted in. Secondly the AS repository is in Access because Analysis Services doesn't have to rely on SQL Server at all, yeah you can migrate it but there are a hell of a lot of implementations running it off of DB2 or Oracle out there. If things were different then I'm sure it would be a native MSDE (like the one Access is running off of now possible) Thirdly the construction of the MDX for reporting services and access would be identical except i don't have to issue a copy of access to everyone who wants to view the reports and i get a hell of a lot of bonus' from an app specificly designed for reporting (e.g. security). Access will always have a place in my heart and a need in the business world, there's no getting away from that, but for reporting out of a cube I wouldn't touch it. No witch hunt, just an opinion..! Steve |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Jamie, Aaron & Steve
Many thanks for all of your feedbacks on using Access reporting to Analysis Services. Please note the main reason something like Access as such a unique place in OLAP reporting is there are so many times when the OLAP cube data needs to be joined with a relational table and most of these some power users would like to do this the data in the relational table could be few hundred records we cannot expect to give a SQL Server or Oracle and DTS to all these people. Power users being familiar with Access would love to get the output of a Analysis Server cube into Access and merge it with other data and report. Last but not the least we are already using reporting services it is not for end users - somebody should not expect us to give Visual Studio .Net to Power users it is still a developer tool. I make a strong case for Access despite all the issues you have pointed out I can give power users access to create adhoc formatted tabular print quality reports customised by them and publish them as Data access pages for web access which I cannot do today on reporting services maybe one day when Microsoft releases something like ActiveViews or whatever they call it as nobody knows when ActiveViews or Yukon or coming. So we want to use something that is already there like Access. I was seeing if I could use Access Pivot reporting against Analysis Services unfortunately Microsoft as not provided that feature as in Excel. Thanks Karen |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
aaron, Yes you are right, the Microsoft Analysis Services repository is stored in Access when it comes out of the box, however standard best practice (access has a nasty habit of getting itself corrupted) is to migrate this to a grown up database like SQL Server as soon as possible. Quote from MSDN "The Access format is used so that users who do not use SQL Server for relational data can still use Analysis Services. However, if you do use SQL Server, migrating the repository to a SQL Server database adds enterprise-level scalability, support, and security. Migrating the repository also enables you to perform coordinated backups of the repository database with a file-based backup of the Data folder. For more information, see "Backup and Recovery" later in this paper. " In terms of Reporting Services VS Access for reporting, Access did have a reporting engine that was away ahead of its time, however time has moved on , and i would recommed Reporting Services not least for its ability to scale effectively .... Sorry that you feel we are dissing Access, i am sure that in some niche areas it still has value to add. Mark |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Open and filter a report from a control value on a data access pag | Mona-ABE | Setting Up & Running Reports | 0 | November 5th, 2004 01:45 PM |
SQL view of messed up action queries | Kendra | Running & Setting Up Queries | 2 | August 31st, 2004 09:53 PM |
How to create graphs in a monthly report where the base data can change | John Clarke | Charts and Charting | 3 | June 25th, 2004 02:22 AM |
Mial merge data base problems | Rachael | Mailmerge | 16 | May 21st, 2004 06:22 PM |
Linking Excel data through Access to use a Form as an Interface | Laura | Links and Linking | 0 | March 23rd, 2004 03:59 PM |